The Shelf Verdict
The Shelf Verdict

Independent reviews, beholden to no one

Agent Nateur

Holi (Pearl)y Whites Cinna-Mint Toothpaste

I spent $28 on designer toothpaste because someone on the internet said it was extraordinary. I have some questions.

Agent Nateur Holi (Pearl)y Whites Cinna-Mint, front, photographed against a light background.

I purchased this product with my own money from thegreenjunglebeautyshop.com.

The Backstory

I used to think spending more than twenty dollars on toothpaste was ridiculous. I would’ve laughed at the suggestion.

Then I watched a random video of someone enthusiastically reviewing Agent Nateur’s Holi (Pearl)y Whites. Their teeth had apparently never felt cleaner. The flavor was amazing. They’d repurchased it several times, which is a fairly convincing endorsement for something as unexciting as toothpaste.

Shortly afterward, I found myself adding a tube to my cart.

It was 20% off, in my defense.

Until then, I’d been using Davids’ whitening toothpaste for sensitive teeth, which also contains hydroxyapatite. I liked the flavor, my teeth felt clean, and I had no complaints. But according to this stranger on the internet, Agent Nateur was operating on an entirely different level.

The hydroxyapatite interested me because I’d been experiencing some sensitivity to cold. That gave me a functional reason to justify the purchase. What I really wanted, though, was an amazing flavor and the kind of clean-mouth feeling that would make ordinary toothpaste seem inadequate.

Brushing my teeth has always been the dullest part of my evening ritual. I can spend ages enjoying my serums and creams, but brushing is something I just want to get through. I thought an expensive toothpaste with an interesting flavor might finally make that part enjoyable, too.

Apparently, $28 wasn’t enough to accomplish that.

The Formula

Agent Nateur has packed quite a lot into Holi (Pearl)y Whites. There’s hydroxyapatite, xylitol, pearl powder, theobromine, a probiotic, Manuka honey extract, and an assortment of botanical ingredients.1Agent Nateur: Holi (Pearl)y Whites ingredient list and product claims, Agent Nateur, 2026

Hydroxyapatite is the ingredient I find most interesting. It’s a calcium phosphate mineral closely related to the material that makes up tooth enamel, and there’s clinical evidence that hydroxyapatite toothpastes can help reduce sensitivity. An eight-week randomized trial found improvements in sensitivity to cold and air with several nano-hydroxyapatite formulations.2B. T. Amaechi et al., Clinical efficacy of nanohydroxyapatite-containing toothpaste at relieving dentin hypersensitivity: an 8 weeks randomized control trial, BDJ Open, 2021

Agent Nateur uses micro-hydroxyapatite without disclosing its concentration. The research gives me a reason to take the ingredient seriously, although it doesn’t tell me how well this particular toothpaste will perform.

Hydrated silica, calcium carbonate, and baking soda provide the more conventional cleaning and polishing action. They can help remove surface stains, which gives the whitening claims a reasonable foundation.

Then there’s the pearl powder, theobromine, probiotic, and botanical supporting cast. Some of these ingredients have interesting research behind them individually, but I haven’t found convincing clinical evidence that this particular combination makes the finished toothpaste substantially better than a simpler formula.

And then we arrive at the honey.

The toothpaste has a distinctly beige-yellow color, which Agent Nateur attributes to its Manuka honey ingredient. I find the idea of cleaning my teeth with something derived from honey slightly amusing. Introducing sugar into the conversation feels rather counterproductive.1Agent Nateur: Holi (Pearl)y Whites ingredient list and product claims, Agent Nateur, 2026

I suspect some of these ingredients do more for the product’s identity than for my teeth. The hydroxyapatite, at least, gives the formula a credible reason to exist beyond its botanical ambitions.

The Experience

I used Holi (Pearl)y Whites twice a day for approximately a week.

The packaging is lovely. Agent Nateur has managed to make toothpaste look like an expensive skincare treatment, and I appreciate that. It’s the sort of tube that looks very nice sitting on a bathroom counter.

I wish I’d enjoyed what was inside nearly as much.

The flavor is described as cinnamon, clove, and mint. That sounded wonderful to me. I imagined something aromatic, with warmth from the cinnamon and a refreshing mint finish.

You do get a little cinnamon and clove at first, but they disappear almost immediately. What remains is mint. It’s mild, certainly, but refreshing. You can feel it, and it leaves your mouth feeling fresh.

There’s nothing unpleasant about the flavor. It’s just an ordinary mint toothpaste experience, which is disappointing when the cinnamon and clove were what made it sound interesting in the first place.

My teeth felt clean, and brushing was perfectly pleasant. I just couldn’t identify the extraordinary sensation that had inspired the review I watched.

I found myself wondering what toothpaste that person had been using before.

In fact, I missed my Davids. Its stronger mint flavor made brushing more enjoyable, and I still preferred it.

Final Words

The daily experience was the main reason I bought this toothpaste, and after a week, I had little desire to keep using it.

I⁠’ll finish the tube. It cleans my teeth, the packaging is pretty, and the formula has some interesting ingredients. But I’d rather go back to Davids, which I enjoy more and costs less.

I⁠’m still curious about Agent Nateur’s skincare. My enthusiasm for exploring the rest of its personal-care range has cooled a little, though.

I wanted designer toothpaste. I got toothpaste.

Sources

  1. Agent Nateur: Holi (Pearl)y Whites ingredient list and product claims, Agent Nateur, 2026.
  2. B. T. Amaechi et al., Clinical efficacy of nanohydroxyapatite-containing toothpaste at relieving dentin hypersensitivity: an 8 weeks randomized control trial, BDJ Open, 2021.

New verdicts, by email.

A short letter when new reviews and essays are published. Nothing else.