The Shelf Verdict
The Shelf Verdict

Independent reviews, beholden to no one

Veronique Gabai

Noire de Mai

A cold rose and patchouli dressed in white and gold, with an unmistakable resemblance to Dior’s Midnight Poison.

Veronique Gabai Noire de Mai, front, photographed against a light background.

I purchased this product with my own money from scentsplit.com.

The Backstory

Dior’s Midnight Poison is one of my favorite fragrances of all time. Unfortunately, Dior discontinued it, and what was once a perfume I could enjoy freely has become something I ration. Every time I reach for one of my bottles, I think about how much it would cost me to replace it.

I⁠’m always on the lookout for Midnight Poison dupes, which is how I came across Noire de Mai by Veronique Gabai. The price made me hesitate, but the notes looked promising and several reviews convinced me to give it a try.

Blind buying a fragrance at this price based on someone else’s idea of what smells like Midnight Poison was a bit of a gamble. I’ve come across enough supposedly identical fragrances that smell nothing alike to me.

Thankfully, I could recognize Midnight Poison in Noire de Mai from the very first spray.

Composition & Notes

The two fragrances have a remarkably similar composition on paper. Both open with bergamot and mandarin, followed by rose over a base of patchouli and amber. Noire de Mai uses two varieties of rose, Centifolia and Damascena, and introduces pink pepper.1Noire de Mai, Veronique Gabai2Midnight Poison Dior, Fragrantica

Interestingly, although vanilla is part of Midnight Poison’s advertised composition and not that of Noire de Mai, Veronique Gabai lists it among the materials used in the fragrance, along with tonka bean and cedarwood.1Noire de Mai, Veronique Gabai

It’s a combination of notes that can smell a little vintage to some people. To me, that cold, almost sour quality of patchouli paired with rose and citrus is one of the most beautiful things in perfumery.

The Experience

Noire de Mai opens a little brighter than Midnight Poison, with the rose more prominently on display. Midnight Poison is darker and has a roundness to it that I associate with its vanilla. Noire de Mai takes that familiar combination of rose and patchouli in a slightly more elegant direction.

I picture them as twins. Midnight Poison is the vampy one dressed entirely in black. Noire de Mai is wearing white, with gold jewelry, looking impeccably put together. Even their bottles seem to agree with me: Midnight Poison in deep blue and Noire de Mai in gold.

What I love about both is that the patchouli retains its cold character throughout. The amber gives the composition body without taking it somewhere warm or overly sweet. It’s a beautiful contrast with the brightness of the citrus and rose.

My biggest disappointment with Noire de Mai is its performance. After about an hour, I struggle to smell it on myself, and the projection is underwhelming. Since I mostly wear fragrance for my own enjoyment, this is particularly frustrating. At $290 for 85 ml, it’s not something I feel entirely comfortable spraying with reckless abandon.

Still, I feel considerably less guilty reaching for it than I do for Midnight Poison.

Final Words

Another fragrance I’ve found that comes close to Midnight Poison is Zafferano by Acqua di Parma, although it lacks some of the roundness I love in the original. Between the two, I have more opportunities to enjoy a scent profile I thought I’d have to ration indefinitely.

I⁠’ve grown to appreciate Noire de Mai for its own character. It’s a beautiful interpretation of one of my favorite combinations in perfumery, and despite its performance, I’d much rather have it in my collection than go without it.

Sources

  1. Noire de Mai, Veronique Gabai.
  2. Midnight Poison Dior, Fragrantica.

New verdicts, by email.

A short letter when new reviews and essays are published. Nothing else.